The author of Hebrews in 12:15-17 warns:
Looking diligently lest any man fail of the grace of God; lest any root of bitterness springing up trouble you, and thereby many be defiled; Lest there be any fornicator, or profane person, as Esau, who for one morsel of meat sold his birthright. For ye know how that afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears.
C. H. Spurgeon wrote concerning the failing of the grace of God:
Under the means of grace, there are many who do “fall short of the grace of God.” They get something that they think is like grace, but it is not the true grace of God, and they ultimately fall from it, and perish. . . . [I]n church fellowship we ought to be very watchful lest the church as a whole should fail through lack of the true grace of God, and especially lest any root of bitterness springing up among us should trouble us, and thereby many be defiled. We must remember that though we are saved by grace, yet grace does not stupefy us, but rather quickens us into action. Though salvation depends upon the merits of Christ, yet those who receive those merits receive with them a faith that produces holiness.
Spurgeon explains that this “failing” is “falling short,” and then “falling short” is not getting “the true grace of God” but “something that they think is like grace.” He says the true grace of God “does not stupefy us, but rather quickens us into action.” The placebo for the true grace of God does not produce holiness.
The true grace of God saves us. Most people want salvation, but they also don’t want the holiness true grace produces. Hebrews uses Esau as an example. He allowed his fleshly desire to keep him from true grace, replacing it with something short of it. God’s grace produces holiness.
Root of Bitterness
Through the years, I’ve read many different opinions about the “root of bitterness.” In the context, it causes a failing of the grace of God. Some say that the root of bitterness is an apostate in the church, like Esau, who then brings about further apostasy from others. Others say that it is sin, which is bitter and defiling. Rick Renner writes:
“It” pictures a person who is continually troubled, harassed, and annoyed by thoughts of how someone else wronged him. The offended person is now so troubled that he is almost emotionally immobilized. Instead of moving on in life, he gets stuck in the muck of that experience, where he wallows day after day in the memories of what happened to him. If that person doesn’t quickly get a grip on himself, he will eventually fulfill the next part of the verse.
Tozer explained it the same way:
The sad and depressing bitter soul will compile a list of slights at which it takes offense and will watch over itself like a mother bear over her cubs. And the figure is apt, for the resentful heart is always surly and suspicious like a she-bear!
Perhaps the preceding verse, verse 14, gives a clue:
Follow peace with all men, and holiness, without which no man shall see the Lord.
Esau lacked peace between he and his father, Isaac, and his brother, Jacob. So many especially today allow the slights, real and otherwise, and even actual sins against them to keep them from the grace of God. They also often use these temporal affronts to justify their lusts, incongruous with the true grace of God. It ultimately reflects on their view of God and His goodness to them.
Postmodern Grace
Spurgeon assessed failing of true grace comes by replacing it with something short of the grace of God. I’m titling what I believe is the most common contemporary replacement for true grace, “postmodern grace” (Jesus Loves Me with postmodern lyrics). It isn’t the grace of God, because it is short of the grace of God.
Postmodern truth is your truth. Postmodern grace is your grace. It doesn’t follow peace, because it allows a grudge and resentment to keep it from that. It doesn’t follow holiness, because it sells holiness for temporal, carnal appetites, like the morsel of Esau. Adherents though count this as the grace of God. They remain bitter with those who reject their failing of the grace of God. The bitterness fuels further rejection of true grace, accompanied, like Esau, by tears of grudge-filled resentment.
Postmodern grace isn’t about pleasing God, but about pleasing self. Postmodern grace self-identifies as grace, which is in fact moral relativism. It doesn’t follow after holiness, but after its own lust.
Regarding the root of bitterness, I think the writer of Hebrews 12:15 is quoting or referencing this:
Deuteronomy 29:18 Lest there should be among you man, or woman, or family, or tribe, whose heart turneth away this day from the LORD our God, to go and serve the gods of these nations; lest there should be among you a root that beareth gall and wormwood;
OT NT, i.e. Anonymous,
I was writing on failing of grace or falling short of grace, so I didn’t give “root of bitterness” a full treatment. It isn’t the subject of the post.
Quoting, referencing, perhaps best alluding to. So what does that mean, saying that it alludes to Deuteronomy 29:18? In other words, both passages use “root of bitterness” of sorts, even though Hebrews 12:15 is Greek and Deuteronomy 29:18, Hebrew. The wording is different, root of bitterness versus root of gall and wormwood (or bitterness). Is the author of Hebrews using this metaphor the same way as Moses was? Or do they relate to one another? Just saying it alludes to Dt 29:18 doesn’t explain.
I’ve read that the root that beareth gall and wormwood is someone in the congregation of Israel whom “bless[es] himself in his heart, saying, I shall have peace, though [he] walk[s] in the imagination of [his] heart” (29:19). In other words, it’s someone presumptuous, counting himself as being born again, even though it’s not showing up in his life. It’s a profession without a possession. He thinks he’s one of the blessed ones, when he’s really one of the cursed ones.
The Greek word translated “bitterness” is the same Greek word used very specifically in Ephesians 4:31. “Bitterness” relates to unmet expectations, not getting what you want, which is a form of discontent or covetousness, which is idolatry. Esau gave up his birthright because he coveted something immediate over something permanent. This is the cause of apostasy. Hebrews 12:14 commands to follow or pursue peace with others. The merciful shall obtain mercy, the peacemakers are the children of God, the meek shall inherit the earth. These all pertain to idols in the heart, which characterized the Pharisees. That’s all I’ll write for now, but it is a fuller development in the context.